top of page

Journal 007: Is a Good Song Still Enough?

Aug 23
7 min read

Estimated reading time: 7 minutes


There was a time when a good song could simply be a good song.


You made it.


You released it.


People heard it.


And if it was good song was enough, it spread.


Of course, it was never quite that simple. There have always been labels, radio, DJs, marketing, money, connections and plenty of other things influencing what became successful.


But ultimately, the music had to carry a significant part of the weight.


A great record could become an anthem because it was a great record.


A brilliant hook could travel.


A ridiculous bassline could become the thing everyone wanted to hear.


A vocal could define a generation.


The music could become bigger than the machinery behind it.


I’m not convinced that’s how it works anymore.


And I think aspiring producers need to understand that.


A good song and a successful song are no longer necessarily the same thing.


That’s probably the simplest way I can put it.


You can make an incredible record and nobody might hear it.


You can make an average record and, if it’s presented in exactly the right way, it can end up everywhere.


And that’s not necessarily because the second record is better.


It’s because something else happened.


The song became attached to a moment.


A video.


A meme.


A trend.


A dance.


A lyric.


A piece of content.


A joke.


A creator.


A particular type of reel.


Suddenly people aren’t necessarily sharing the song because they love the song.


They’re sharing the thing around the song.


And the song comes along for the ride.


We’ve always been manipulated by repetition.


This isn’t new.


Radio has been doing it for decades.


If a major station decides that a particular record is important, they can put it into heavy rotation.


You hear it on your way to work.


You hear it at lunchtime.


You hear it on the way home.


You hear it tomorrow.


And the day after.


Eventually, something strange happens.


You stop hearing it as a new piece of music.


You start recognising it.


And familiarity is incredibly powerful.


You might initially think:


“What the fuck is this?”


Then a few days later you find yourself humming the chorus.


A week later you know the words.


A couple of weeks later you don’t even question whether you like it.


It’s just part of the musical landscape.


The record has become familiar.


And familiarity can very easily be mistaken for preference.


Social media has taken that mechanism and handed it to everybody.


That’s the big difference.


Radio had gatekeepers.


Social media has billions of tiny broadcasters.


And those broadcasters can repeat something relentlessly.


You don’t need a radio programmer to decide when the audience hears your song anymore.


You can decide.


You can put the same clip out tomorrow.


And again the day after.


And again next week.


You can use different videos.


Different hooks.


Different captions.


Different creators.


Different contexts.


You can keep putting the same thirty seconds of a record in front of people until they can’t escape it.


And here’s where I think things get really interesting.


The song can become successful because the content is successful.


Not necessarily the other way around.


The content can become the hit.


I’ve seen this happen more and more.


Someone creates a silly little video.


There’s a particular line in a song.


People find it funny.


Someone else copies the format.


Then someone else.


Then someone with a bigger audience does it.


Suddenly everyone is doing it.


And the track becomes attached to the trend.


At that point, the song almost becomes a piece of social media infrastructure.


People are using it because everyone else is using it.


And that’s where the snowball begins.


One person uses it.


Ten people use it.


A hundred.


A thousand.


Ten thousand.


And eventually you’re hearing the same piece of music everywhere.


It becomes unavoidable.


And when something becomes unavoidable, it becomes familiar.


And when something becomes familiar…


People often start liking it.


This isn’t necessarily stupidity.


And I don’t think we should dismiss people for participating in this.


Humans have always followed things.


We like belonging.


We like shared experiences.


We like knowing the thing everyone else knows.


We like being part of a moment.


Social media has simply amplified that behaviour to an extraordinary level.


And there is another factor at play.


Everyone wants attention.


Everyone wants reach.


Everyone wants followers.


Everyone wants their content to perform.


So if someone sees a particular song getting massive numbers and thinks:


“I’ll use that song too.”


I can’t really blame them.


They’re playing the game that the platform has created.


And if the platform rewards them for it, why wouldn’t they?


But this changes what aspiring producers need to understand.


If you’re coming into music now thinking:


“I’ll just make a brilliant record and the music will speak for itself.”


I admire the sentiment.


But I don’t think it’s a particularly reliable business strategy anymore.


You can make a brilliant record.


You should make a brilliant record.


But you also need to understand how people are going to encounter it.


How are they going to discover it?


What’s going to make them stop scrolling?


What’s going to make them remember it?


What’s going to make them use it?


What’s going to make somebody send it to their mate?


What’s going to make someone hear ten seconds of it and think:


“What the fuck is that?”


That’s a different skill.


And it’s becoming increasingly important.


The uncomfortable truth is that the song might not be the marketing anymore.


The song might be the raw material.


The actual marketing is the ecosystem built around it.


That’s a massive shift.


Because historically, you could have a record that generated its own momentum.


A DJ played it.


People heard it.


Other DJs wanted it.


Clubs reacted.


Radio picked it up.


The record sold.


People talked about it.


It grew.


Now you can manufacture a huge amount of that momentum yourself.


And that’s both exciting and terrifying.


Because it means you don’t necessarily need permission.


But it also means there is an enormous amount of noise.


Everybody can do it.


Everybody can post.


Everybody can push.


Everybody can create a trend.


Everybody can try to manufacture a moment.


Which means we’re all fighting for the same few seconds of someone’s attention.


And that brings me back to the music.


Because here’s the bit I don’t want people to misunderstand.


I’m not saying:


“Don’t bother making good music.”


Quite the opposite.


Make the best music you possibly can.


But understand what you’re actually trying to achieve.


Because there is a difference between:


making a good record


and


making a record that becomes successful.


They’re related.


But they’re not identical.


And I think a lot of producers are still operating as though they are.


Personally, I find this difficult.


I’m probably not particularly well suited to this part of the modern music industry.


I’m too stubborn.


I’m too honest with myself.


If I think a record is shit, I think it’s shit.


Even if everyone else loves it.


And if I don’t like a track, I don’t particularly want to start using it in my content simply because I know the algorithm might reward me for doing so.


I know there are people who are much better at that than me.


And honestly?


I admire them for it.


Because it requires a certain ability to detach yourself from the music and look at it as a product.


I struggle with that.


Music still means too much to me.


But I also recognise that if you’re trying to build something commercially today, you can’t completely ignore the environment you’re operating in.


So where does that leave us?


I think we’re entering a period where the definition of a “hit” is changing.


A hit might not start with the song anymore.


It might start with a fifteen-second clip.


A meme.


A creator.


A trend.


A moment.


And the song becomes the soundtrack to that moment.


Sometimes that will produce an incredible record that genuinely deserves the attention.


Sometimes it won’t.


And that’s the interesting part.


Because the mechanism doesn’t necessarily care.


The algorithm isn’t sitting there judging the quality of your songwriting.


It’s measuring behaviour.


Did people stop?


Did they watch?


Did they replay?


Did they share?


Did they comment?


Did they use the sound?


Did somebody else copy it?


That’s what matters to the machine.


And perhaps that’s the biggest lesson for anyone coming into music now.


Don’t confuse attention with quality.


They’re not the same thing.


Don’t confuse familiarity with greatness.


They’re not the same thing.


And don’t confuse virality with longevity.


They’re definitely not the same thing.


A song can explode online and disappear six weeks later.


Another song can quietly build an audience for five years.


Both can be successful.


Just in completely different ways.


Maybe the question isn’t “Is this a good song?”


Maybe the better question is:


“What happens when someone hears it?”


Because that’s the game now.


The song still matters.


The craft still matters.


The writing still matters.


The production still matters.


But the journey from making the record to someone actually caring about the record has become an entirely different discipline.


And if you’re an aspiring artist or producer, I’d encourage you to learn both.


Make something worth hearing.


Then learn how to get people to hear it.


Just don’t convince yourself that one automatically guarantees the other.


Because these days…


a great song can still die quietly.


And an average song can become absolutely fucking enormous.


That’s not necessarily fair.


But I’m not sure the music industry has ever been particularly interested in being fair.


It’s interested in attention.


And right now, attention is the currency.


—


Raff Di Renzo


Founder, Eleven One One Audio


Make the music. But understand the machine that decides whether people hear it.

Comments


©2026 by Eleven One One Audio.

bottom of page